Mass Ave location now open: 881 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204. Noblesville & Mass Ave open 7 days a week.

New Puzzles

Ashley Woodson Bailey - Bouquet (750 pc shaped puzzle)

Ashley Woodson Bailey - Bouquet (750 pc shaped puzzle)

Regular price $19.99
Artichoke Floral (500 pc puzzle)

Artichoke Floral (500 pc puzzle)

Regular price $13.99
Songbirds (500 pc puzzle)

Songbirds (500 pc puzzle)

Regular price $13.99
Feathers (500 pc gold foil puzzle)

Feathers (500 pc gold foil puzzle)

Regular price $14.99
Gray Malin - The Beach (500 pc double-sided puzzle)

Gray Malin - The Beach (500 pc double-sided puzzle)

Regular price $24.99
Succulent Garden (500 pc double-sided puzzle)

Succulent Garden (500 pc double-sided puzzle)

Regular price $15.99
4D Toronto, Canada

4D Toronto, Canada

Sale price $35.99 Regular price $39.99
4D Imperial China (National Geographic)

4D Imperial China (National Geographic)

Regular price $24.99
4D Las Vegas, USA

4D Las Vegas, USA

Sale price $35.99 Regular price $39.99
4D Boston, USA

4D Boston, USA

Sale price $35.99 Regular price $39.99
4D Los Angeles, USA

4D Los Angeles, USA

Sale price $35.99 Regular price $39.99
Aurora Borealis (50 pc wooden puzzle)

Aurora Borealis (50 pc wooden puzzle)

Regular price $49.99
Disney Museum (9000 pc puzzle)

Disney Museum (9000 pc puzzle)

Regular price $139.99
Disney Collection - Collector Pins 750 pc Puzzle

Disney Collection - Collector Pins 750 pc Puzzle

Regular price $12.99
Disney Fine Art - The Lion King (1000 pc puzzle)

Disney Fine Art - The Lion King (1000 pc puzzle)

Regular price $13.99
Disney Fine Art - Enchantment of Snow White (1000 pc puzzle)

Disney Fine Art - Enchantment of Snow White (1000 pc puzzle)

Regular price $13.99
Disney Panoramic - Toy Story (700 pc puzzle)

Disney Panoramic - Toy Story (700 pc puzzle)

Regular price $12.99
Disney Panoramic - Fab 5 (700 pc puzzle)

Disney Panoramic - Fab 5 (700 pc puzzle)

Regular price $12.99
Disney Panoramic - Incredibles 2 (700 pc puzzle)

Disney Panoramic - Incredibles 2 (700 pc puzzle)

Regular price $12.99
Disney Pixar 5-in-1 Multipack Puzzles Includes - Finding Dory, The Incredibles 2, Brave, Coco, and Ratatouille

Disney Pixar 5-in-1 Multipack Puzzles Includes - Finding Dory, The Incredibles 2, Brave, Coco, and Ratatouille

Regular price $18.99
Thomas Kinkade - The Good Life (1000 pc puzzle)

Thomas Kinkade - The Good Life (1000 pc puzzle)

Regular price $12.99
Thomas Kinkade - Courage - (1000 pc puzzle)

Thomas Kinkade - Courage - (1000 pc puzzle)

Regular price $12.99
Thomas Kinkade Round - Dogwood Chapel (550 pc puzzle)

Thomas Kinkade Round - Dogwood Chapel (550 pc puzzle)

Regular price $13.99
Thomas Kinkade Round - Lakeside Manor (550 pc puzzle)

Thomas Kinkade Round - Lakeside Manor (550 pc puzzle)

Regular price $13.99